| Maureen O'Sullivan | Ann | 
    
    
      | Joel McCrea | Tony | 
    
    
      | Lewis Stone | District Attorney | 
    
    
      | Louis Calhern | Smiley | 
    
    
      | Edgar Kennedy | Sweeney | 
    
    
      | Adrienne Ames | Betty | 
    
    
      | Robert Greig | Peedles | 
    
    
      | Noel Madison | Joe Metz | 
    
    
      | Granville Bates | Casey | 
    
    
      | William B. Davidson | Collins | 
    
    
      | Richard Powell | Lee | 
    
    
      | Erville Alderson | Constable | 
    
    
      | Gertrude Short | Gertie | 
    
    
      | Ernie Alexander | Steve - Man Bringing Newspapers (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Stanley Andrews | Jury Foreman (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Brooks Benedict | Casino Manager in Nightclub (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Margaret Bloodgood | Matron With Ann (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Harry C. Bradley | Third Juror Talking to Mike (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Don Brodie | Reporter (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | James P. Burtis | Second State Trooper (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Clay Clement | Smiley's Henchman (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Sayre Dearing | Party Guest (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | John Dilson | Juror Talking to Mike (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Billy Dooley | Mr. Sneider - Bumped by Ann (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | James Flavin | Mac - Policeman (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Ralf Harolde | Monk Shelby (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Eddie Hart | Andy - Smiley's Henchman (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Howard Hickman | Dr. Griffith (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Al Hill | Smiley's Henchman (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Arthur Housman | Art - Waiter at Party (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Boyd Irwin | Judge at Ann's Trial (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Eddie Kane | Nightclub Headwaiter (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Isabelle Keith | Telephone Operator (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | John Kelly | Truck Driver Hitting Police Car (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Charles Lane | Defense Attorney Herman (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Michael Mark | Smiley's Henchman (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Charles Marsh | Reporter (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Harry McCoy | Businessman (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Sam McDaniel | Oscar - Show Boat Washroom Attendant (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Tom McGuire | Court Officer (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Ivan Miller | First State Trooper (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Bert Moorhouse | Reporter (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Bob Murphy | Mike - Dissenting Juror (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Edward Norris | Man on Phone at Party (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Barry Norton | Nightclub Patron (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Dave O'Brien | Steve - Tap Dancer at Baxter's Party (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Frank O'Connor | Policeman (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Paul Parry | Minor Role (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Lee Phelps | Detective Charlie Beale (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Jack Rice | Man Walking With Cane in Hotel (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Dick Rush | Detective (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Hector V. Sarno | Juror in Backgound of Jury Room (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Frank Sheridan | Judge at Baxter's Proceedings (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Carl Stockdale | Court Clerk Reading Verdict (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Harry Strang | Police Dispatcher (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Phil Tead | Second Juror Talking to Mike (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Charles Trowbridge | Assistant District Attorney (uncredited) | 
    
    
      | Gayne Whitman | Attorney (uncredited) |