| This American version of the British comedy panel features team captains joined by a stellar cast of celebrity guests who weave elaborate tales… that may or may not be the truth. Competing teams then ask questions and watch body language to determine which are outrageous but true, and which are made-up stories. |
| Name | Character | Episodes |
|---|---|---|
| Aasif Mandvi | Self - Host | 13 |
| Matt Walsh | Self - Team Captain | 13 |
| Ali Wentworth | Self | 2 |
| Michael Ian Black | Self | 2 |
| Fisher Stevens | Self | 1 |
| Kurt Fuller | Himself | 1 |
| Adam Pally | 1 | |
| Richard Kind | Self | 1 |
| Michael Urie | Self | 1 |
| Andrea Martin | Self | 1 |
| Laura Benanti | Self | 1 |
| Heléne Yorke | Self | 1 |
| Dylan Baker | Self | 1 |
| Sarah Steele | Herself | 1 |
| Bridget Everett | Self | 1 |
| Robin de Jesús | Self | 1 |
| Becky Ann Baker | Self | 1 |
| Santino Fontana | Self | 1 |
| Amy Carlson | Self | 1 |
| Cole Escola | Himself | 1 |
| Maulik Pancholy | Self | 1 |
| Isaac Mizrahi | Self | 1 |
| Nyambi Nyambi | Self | 1 |
| Eugene Mirman | Self | 1 |
| John Hodgman | Self | 1 |
| Krysta Rodriguez | Self | 1 |
| Jordan Klepper | Self | 1 |
| Christian Finnegan | Self | 1 |
| Jordan Carlos | Self | 1 |
| Rachel Feinstein | Self | 1 |
| Chris Gethard | Self | 1 |
| Negin Farsad | Self | 1 |
| Jill Kargman | 1 | |
| Gizelle Bryant | 1 | |
| Hari Kondabolu | Self | 1 |
| Michael Boatman | Self | 1 |
| Julie Klausner | Self | 1 |