| Name | Character | Episodes |
|---|---|---|
| Mikey Day | Self - Host | 24 |
| Chris Witaske | Self - Judge | 2 |
| Blake Anderson | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Joel McHale | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Lauren Lapkus | Herself | 1 |
| Bobby Moynihan | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Heidi Gardner | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Chrishell Stause | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Chloe Fineman | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Fortune Feimster | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Arturo Castro | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Maz Jobrani | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Dan Ahdoot | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Jay Pharoah | Himself | 1 |
| Taylor Tomlinson | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Kirby Howell-Baptiste | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Chris Redd | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Nico Santos | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Lyric Lewis | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Finesse Mitchell | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Tony Rock | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Loni Love | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Jon Gabrus | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Michael Yo | Self - Judge | 1 |
| London Hughes | Herself | 1 |
| Camille Kostek | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Rebecca Black | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Courtney Parchman | Self - Judge | 1 |