| Name | Character | Episodes |
|---|---|---|
| Ryan Eggold | Ed Ramsey | 8 |
| Alona Tal | Kayla Craig | 8 |
| Aldis Hodge | Alex Cross | 8 |
| Jennifer Wigmore | Chief Anderson | 8 |
| Isaiah Mustafa | John Sampson | 8 |
| Eloise Mumford | Shannon Witmer | 8 |
| Juanita Jennings | Regina 'Nana Mama' Cross | 8 |
| Samantha Walkes | Elle Montiero | 8 |
| Stacie Greenwell | Shawna De Lackner | 7 |
| Johnny Ray Gill | Bobby Trey | 7 |
| Sharon Taylor | Oracene Massey | 6 |
| Mercedes de la Zerda | Amielynn Vega | 6 |
| Dwain Murphy | Akbar | 5 |
| Karen Robinson | Miss Nancy | 5 |
| Jason Rogel | Chris Wu | 4 |
| Richard Waugh | Pendleton Whitney | 4 |
| Siobhan Murphy | Tania Hightower | 4 |
| Matt Baram | Val Hardy | 4 |
| Ashley Rios | Malika Goodspeed | 4 |
| Kristin Booth | Dr. Marla Daine | 3 |
| Ryan Allen | Peter Lenox | 3 |
| Jessica Clement | Deirdre Nolan | 3 |
| Michael Rhoades | Roger Thorn | 2 |
| Kimberly S. Fairbanks | Mother Goodspeed | 2 |
| Rob Stewart | Lawrence Buckley | 1 |
| Joe Bostick | Townie | 1 |
| Yanna McIntosh | Dr. Finlay | 1 |
| Christina Wren | Kat Myers | 1 |
| Bobby Daniels | Shorty | 1 |
| Charles Jarman | Morris | 1 |
| Ryan Allen | Delivery Man | 1 |
| Lara Amersey | Sheree | 1 |
| Jim Annan | Dex Notarile | 1 |
| Von Flores | Judge Matlof | 1 |
| Melissa Murray-Mutch | Ms. Cubbins | 1 |
| Douglas E. Hughes | Warden McBride | 1 |
| Neil Whitely | Judge Kittworth | 1 |
| Kathryn Taylor Smith | Young Nana Mama Cross | 1 |
| Sarah Camacho | Line | 1 |
| Joseph Pierre | Jared | 1 |
| Vieslav Krystyan | Lem Futa | 1 |
| Jeremy Walmsley | Dick Miller | 1 |
| Briana Starks | Melanie Norris | 1 |
| Golden Madison | Charlotte | 1 |
| Adrian Petriw | Stan Cikola | 1 |