| Name | Character | Episodes |
|---|---|---|
| Bob Saget | Self - host | 10 |
| Bill Engvall | Self - Panelist | 5 |
| Melissa Peterman | Self - Panelist | 4 |
| Carson Kressley | Self - Panelist | 4 |
| Fortune Feimster | Self - Panelist | 3 |
| Mickey Guyton | Self - Panelist | 3 |
| Caroline Rhea | Self - Panelist | 3 |
| Gary Busey | Self - Panelist | 2 |
| Marie Osmond | Self - Center Square | 2 |
| Chris Sullivan | Self - Panelist | 1 |
| Jana Kramer | Self - Panelist | 1 |
| Jana Kramer | Self - Contestant | 1 |
| Mickey Guyton | Self - Contestant | 1 |
| Jon Reep | Self - Panelist | 1 |
| Ty Pennington | Self - Panelist | 1 |
| Jimmie Allen | Self - Contestant | 1 |
| Jimmie Allen | Self - Panelist | 1 |
| Tanya Tucker | Self - Contestant | 1 |
| Dusty Slay | Self - Panelist | 1 |