| Name | Character | Episodes |
|---|---|---|
| Jim Ross | 87 | |
| Steven Haworth | 87 | |
| Konosuke Takeshita | Konosuke Takeshita | 17 |
| Paige Wooding | Jamie Hayter | 9 |
| Phil Brooks | CM Punk | 8 |
| Daniel Wheeler | Cash Wheeler | 8 |
| Joseph Robinson | Juice Robinson | 8 |
| Tony Schiavone | Tony Schiavone | 7 |
| Manuel Alfonso Andrade Oropeza | Andrade El Idolo | 7 |
| Steven Haworth | Nigel McGuinness | 7 |
| Richard Starks | Ricky Starks | 7 |
| Jason Reso | Christian Cage | 6 |
| Miroslav Barnyashev | Miro | 6 |
| Matthew Adams | Buddy Matthews | 6 |
| Nathan Blauvelt | Brody King | 6 |
| Shayna Wayne | Shayna Wayne | 6 |
| Samuel Ratsch | Darby Allin | 6 |
| Tom Büdgen | Malakai Black | 5 |
| Nuufolau Joel Seanoa | Samoa Joe | 5 |
| Danielle Paultre | Willow Nightingale | 5 |
| Michael Cuellari | QT Marshall | 4 |
| Aurelian Smith Jr. | Jake the Snake Roberts | 4 |
| Samuel Ratsch | 4 | |
| Toni Rossall | Toni Storm | 3 |
| Maxwell Jacob Friedman | MJF | 3 |
| Dori Prange | Ruby Soho | 3 |
| Shayna Wayne | Mother Wayne | 3 |
| Minoru Suzuki | Minoru Suzuki | 2 |
| Jamine Benitez | Mercedes Martinez | 2 |
| Brian Button | Brian Cage | 1 |
| Chris Irvine | Chris Jericho | 1 |
| Dustin Runnels | Dustin Rhodes | 1 |
| Steve Borden | Sting | 1 |
| Jim Ross | Jim Ross | 1 |
| Renee Paquette | Renee Paquette | 1 |
| Bryan Danielson | Bryan Danielson | 1 |
| Tetsuya Naito | Tetsuya Naito | 1 |
| Monty Sopp | Billy Gunn | 1 |
| Stephon Strickland | Swerve Strickland | 1 |
| Hiroshi Tanahashi | Hiroshi Tanahashi | 1 |
| William Morrissey | Big Bill | 1 |
| Jonathan Cruz Rivera | Serpentico | 1 |
| Nicholas Comoroto | Nick Comoroto | 1 |
| RJ Skinner | RJ City | 1 |
| Christopher Lindsey | Roderick Strong | 1 |
| Adrienne Reese | Athena | 1 |
| Paige Wooding | 1 |