| Name | Character | Episodes |
|---|---|---|
| Josh Ruben | Mama | 12 |
| Elaine Carroll | Plum | 12 |
| David Kerns | Photographer | 1 |
| Nicole Byer | Psychic | 1 |
| Josh Ruben | Maybe Daddy | 1 |
| Eric Edelstein | Waldo | 1 |
| John Gemberling | Pawn Shop Owner | 1 |
| Nick Mundy | Stan | 1 |
| Joe Wengert | Good Samaritan | 1 |
| Matthew J. McCarthy | Crazy Man | 1 |