| Name | Character | Episodes |
|---|---|---|
| Tony Shalhoub | Frank Russo | 8 |
| Kal Penn | Gil Bartis | 8 |
| Jerry O'Connell | Stuart Weber | 8 |
| Christopher Nicholas Smith | Carter Thomas | 8 |
| Rebecca Breeds | Abby Russo | 8 |
| Aya Cash | Claire | 2 |
| Bre Blair | Amy | 2 |
| Maz Jobrani | Vic | 2 |
| Fiona Gubelmann | Sara | 1 |
| Alan Ruck | Minister | 1 |
| Dave Foley | Carter's Dad | 1 |
| Gia Carides | Frank's Ex-Wife | 1 |
| Romy Rosemont | Carter's Mom | 1 |
| John Brotherton | Handsome Guy | 1 |
| Raymond Ochoa | Jacob | 1 |