| Name | Character | Episodes |
|---|---|---|
| Tim Bagley | Toby Pearson | 40 |
| Ryan Caltagirone | Hot Dad | 17 |
| Ella McKenzie Gross | Julie | 2 |
| Mary Sohn | Denise | 2 |
| Raegan Revord | Melinda | 1 |
| Haley Joel Osment | Damien | 1 |
| Izaac Wang | Caleb | 1 |
| Alyvia Alyn Lind | Annika | 1 |
| Siena Agudong | Tiffany | 1 |
| August Maturo | Kyle | 1 |
| Judy Kain | Shirley | 1 |
| Jolene Purdy | Siobhan | 1 |
| Nicolas Cantu | Quinn (as Nicholas Cantu) | 1 |
| Landon Gordon | Marcus | 1 |
| Herbert Russell | Glenn | 1 |
| Rowan Smyth | Bobby Ray | 1 |
| Ella Jay Basco | Amanda | 1 |
| Winslow Fegley | Daniel | 1 |
| Paxton Booth | Marco | 1 |
| Noelle E Parker | Francine | 1 |
| Adam Korson | Kyle | 1 |
| Santiago Veizaga | Jermaine | 1 |
| Gemma Brooke Allen | Eliza | 1 |
| Jaeden Bettencourt | Nathan (uncredited) | 1 |
| Callan Farris | Kadir Siddiqui | 1 |
| Jenna Davis | Ashley | 1 |
| Anna Campbell | Lil | 1 |