| Name | Character | Episodes |
|---|---|---|
| Jeff Tremaine | Himself | 8 |
| Nick Nemeth | Dolph Ziggler | 7 |
| Mike Mizanin | The Miz | 6 |
| Kofi Sarkodie-Mensah | Kofi Kingston | 6 |
| Heath Miller | Heath Slater | 5 |
| Matthew Cardona | Zack Ryder | 4 |
| Renee Paquette | Renee Young | 3 |
| Victoria Crawford | Alicia Fox | 3 |
| Rosa Mendes | Rosa Mendes | 3 |
| Austin Watson | Xavier Woods | 3 |
| Martin Wright | Boogeyman | 3 |
| Curtis Hussey | Fandango | 3 |
| Dylan Postl | Hornswoggle | 3 |
| Trinity Fatu | Naomi | 2 |
| Nattie Neidhart-Wilson | Natalya | 2 |
| Jonathan Good | Dean Ambrose | 2 |
| Ariane Nicole Andrew | Cameron | 2 |
| Booker Huffman, Jr. | Booker T | 2 |
| Paul Wight | Big Show | 2 |
| Glenn Jacobs | Kane | 2 |
| Danielle Moinet | Summer Rae | 2 |
| Benjamin Satterly | Neville | 2 |
| Ron Killings | R-Truth | 2 |
| Bryan Kelly | Byron Saxton | 2 |
| Colby Lopez | Seth Rollins | 2 |
| Jim Duggan | "Hacksaw" Jim Duggan | 1 |
| Cody Rhodes | Himself | 1 |
| Mercedes Varnado | Sasha Banks | 1 |
| Jason Reso | Christian | 1 |
| Stuart Bennett | Bad News Barrett | 1 |
| Gene Okerlund | Himself | 1 |
| John Layfield | JBL | 1 |
| Miroslav Barnyashev | Rusev | 1 |
| Ashley Fliehr | Charlotte | 1 |
| Natalie Eva Marie | Eva Marie | 1 |
| Dave England | Himself | 1 |
| Ted DiBiase Sr. | Ted DiBiase | 1 |
| Jimmy Hart | Himself | 1 |
| Ettore Ewen | Big-E | 1 |
| Ettore Ewen | Big E | 1 |
| Taylor Rotunda | Bo Dallas | 1 |
| Thaddeus Bullard | Titus O'Neil | 1 |
| Anthony Carelli | Santino Marella | 1 |
| Tenille Dashwood | Emma | 1 |
| Aurelian Smith Jr. | Jake "The Snake" Roberts | 1 |
| Joe Hennig | Curtis Axel | 1 |