| Name | Character | Episodes |
|---|---|---|
| Mike Myers | Tommy Maitland - Host | 17 |
| Will Arnett | Self - Judge | 9 |
| Ken Jeong | Self - Judge | 4 |
| Regina Hall | Self - Judge | 2 |
| Anthony Anderson | Self - Judge | 2 |
| Rob Riggle | Self - Judge | 2 |
| Fred Armisen | Self - Judge | 2 |
| Maya Rudolph | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Megan Fox | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Elizabeth Banks | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Zach Galifianakis | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Andy Samberg | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Courteney Cox | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Jack Black | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Will Forte | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Jennifer Aniston | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Alison Brie | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Jason Sudeikis | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Isla Fisher | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Kristen Schaal | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Alyson Hannigan | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Priyanka Chopra Jonas | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Joel McHale | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Wendi McLendon-Covey | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Tracee Ellis Ross | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Lil Rel Howery | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Yvette Nicole Brown | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Jimmy Kimmel | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Chelsea Handler | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Dana Carvey | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Tony Hale | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Sharon Osbourne | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Brad Paisley | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Ken Marino | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Selma Blair | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Ed Helms | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Rita Wilson | Self - Judge | 1 |