| Home bakers who have a poor track record in the kitchen seek redemption -- and cash -- on this series. In each episode, three contestants try their hand at re-creating edible masterpieces. The projects don't always turn out great, but whichever amateur baker comes closest to a successful dessert by the end of the episode takes home the $10,000 prize, which they might want to use on baking lessons. Comic Nicole Byer and renowned pastry chef Jacques Torres host. It's part reality contest, part hot mess. |
| Name | Character | Episodes |
|---|---|---|
| Nicole Byer | Self - Host / Judge | 43 |
| Joey King | Self - Guest Baker | 1 |
| Adam Scott | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Lana Condor | Self - Pop-In Guest | 1 |
| Mary Mouser | Self - Guest Judge | 1 |
| Jack McBrayer | Self - Guest Baker | 1 |
| Chelsea Peretti | Self - Guest Judge | 1 |
| Emmy Raver-Lampman | Self - Guest Judge | 1 |
| Sam Richardson | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Matt Walsh | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Gianni DeCenzo | Self - Guest Baker | 1 |
| Bobby Lee | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Jason Mantzoukas | Self | 1 |
| Lil Rel Howery | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Felicia Day | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Andrea Savage | Self - Judge | 1 |
| June Diane Raphael | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Betsy Sodaro | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Sasheer Zamata | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Hunter King | Self - Guest Baker | 1 |
| Brian Posehn | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Wayne Brady | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Fortune Feimster | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Art Smith | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Antoni Porowski | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Ron Funches | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Reggie Watts | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Tone Bell | Self - Guest Judge | 1 |
| Jon Gabrus | Self - Judge | 1 |
| A$AP Ferg | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Rosanna Pansino | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Bobby Berk | Self - Guest Baker | 1 |
| Sylvia Weinstock | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Jay Chandrasekhar | Self - Judge | 1 |
| Jonathan Van Ness | Self - Guest Baker | 1 |