| Name | Character | Episodes |
|---|---|---|
| Tony Schiavone | 38 | |
| Albert Christian Hardie Jr. | ACH | 9 |
| Pentagón Jr. | 7 | |
| Stephon Strickland | Shane Strickland | 7 |
| John Hennigan | 4 | |
| Hassan Hamin Assad | MVP | 4 |
| Donald Hager Jr. | Jake Hager | 4 |
| Maxwell Jacob Friedman | 4 | |
| Samuel Alton Johnston | Sami Callihan | 4 |
| Samuel Alton Johnston | Sami callihan | 4 |
| Nathan Blauvelt | Brody King | 3 |
| Pierre Carl Ouellet | PCO | 2 |
| Nelson Rodriguez Erazo | Homicide | 2 |
| Richard Swann | 2 | |
| Richard Swann | Rich swann | 2 |
| Chris Parks | Abyss | 1 |
| Samula Anoa'i | Samu | 1 |
| Donald Hager Jr. | Jake hager | 1 |
| Kevin Sullivan | 1 | |
| Maxwell Jacob Friedman | Maxwell Jacob Friedman | 1 |
| Chelsea Cardona | Chelsea Green | 1 |
| Joseph Ryan Meehan | Joey Ryan | 1 |
| Tom Laughlin | Tommy Dreamer | 1 |
| Richard Swann | Rich Swan | 1 |
| Santana Garrett | 1 | |
| Harry Smith | Davey Boy Smith Jr. | 1 |
| Harry Smith | Davey boy Smith Jr. | 1 |
| Brian Heffron | Blue Meanie | 1 |
| Dylan Postl | Swoggle | 1 |