| Name | Character | Episodes |
|---|---|---|
| Teal Sherer | Teal | 9 |
| Felicia Day | Felicia | 3 |
| Gary Anthony Williams | Charles | 2 |
| Marissa Cuevas | Marissa | 2 |
| Eric Acosta | Milo | 2 |
| Mindy Sterling | Maggie | 1 |
| Patricia Tallman | Casey | 1 |
| Jake Stormoen | Waiter #1 | 1 |
| Carlos Knight | Sign Spinner | 1 |
| Sandeep Parikh | Sandeep | 1 |
| Amy Okuda | Amy | 1 |
| Tara Platt | Teale's Friend | 1 |
| Andrew Anderson | Club Patron | 1 |
| Geri Jewell | Geri | 1 |
| Laura Meadows | Restaurant Patron | 1 |
| Adriane McLean | Lady in Yellow | 1 |
| Jason Charles Miller | Teale's Friend | 1 |