| Name | Character | Episodes |
|---|---|---|
| Phil Brooks | CM Punk | 38 |
| Booker Huffman, Jr. | Booker T | 38 |
| Renee Paquette | Renee Young | 38 |
| Jason Reso | Christian | 26 |
| Mark Henry | Mark Henry | 9 |
| Adrienne Reese | Ember Moon | 8 |
| Paul Levesque | Triple H | 4 |
| Andrew Galloway | Drew McIntyre | 4 |
| Nuufolau Joel Seanoa | Samoa Joe | 3 |
| Colby Lopez | Seth Rollins | 3 |
| Adam Copeland | Edge | 2 |
| Elizabeth Copeland | Beth Phoenix | 2 |
| Óscar Gutiérrez | Rey Mysterio | 2 |
| Rebecca Quin | Becky Lynch | 2 |
| Nikki Garcia | Nikki Bella | 2 |
| Mick Foley | Mick Foley | 2 |
| Michael Hickenbottom | Shawn Michaels | 2 |
| Ashley Fliehr | Charlotte Flair | 2 |
| Kofi Sarkodie-Mensah | Kofi Kingston | 2 |
| Brie Garcia | Brie Bella | 2 |
| Austin Watson | Xavier Woods | 2 |
| Ettore Ewen | Big E | 2 |
| Amanda Saccomanno | Mandy Rose | 2 |
| David Arquette | David Arquette | 1 |
| Dwayne Johnson | The Rock | 1 |
| John Cena | John Cena | 1 |
| William Shatner | William Shatner | 1 |
| Gabriel Iglesias | Gabriel Iglesias | 1 |
| Steve Austin | Stone Cold Steve Austin | 1 |
| Allen Jones | AJ Styles | 1 |
| Rob Gronkowski | Rob Gronkowski | 1 |
| Freddie Prinze Jr. | Freddie Prinze Jr. | 1 |
| Nattie Neidhart-Wilson | Natalya | 1 |
| Mike Mizanin | The Miz | 1 |
| Stephanie McMahon | Stephanie McMahon | 1 |
| Tom Büdgen | Aleister Black | 1 |
| Joshua Fatu | Jey Uso | 1 |
| Alexis Cabrera | Alexa Bliss | 1 |
| Jeff Hardy | Jeff Hardy | 1 |
| Kenneth Crawford | Montez Ford | 1 |
| Claudio Castagnoli | Cesaro | 1 |
| Joe Anoaʻi | Roman Reigns | 1 |
| John Layfield | JBL | 1 |
| Jonathan Fatu Jr. | Jimmy Uso | 1 |
| Merced Solis | Ricky 'The Dragon' Steamboat | 1 |
| Bret Hart | Bret 'The Hitman' Hart | 1 |
| Jeffrey Jarrett | Jeff Jarrett | 1 |
| Bryan Danielson | Daniel Bryan | 1 |
| Adam Scherr | Braun Strowman | 1 |
| Kevin Steen | Kevin Owens | 1 |
| Thomas Pestock | King Corbin | 1 |
| Gary Gordon | Angelo Dawkins | 1 |
| Windham Rotunda | Bray Wyatt | 1 |
| Frank Caliendo | Frank Caliendo | 1 |
| Nikola Bogojević | Otis | 1 |
| Jeff Sciullo | Elias | 1 |
| Cassandra Lee McIntosh | Peyton Royce | 1 |